Christie Keith

Are pets calmer and less stressed without their owners present during veterinary exams? A recent study partially funded by Fear Free sheds some light on this often-controversial subject.

There’s a lot of disagreement among veterinary professionals on how to interpret the emotional cues displayed by pets when removed from their owners. Many pet parents also object to having their pets taken away to a treatment area. While this practice was extremely common during the COVID pandemic, it was a normal part of many veterinary visits before lockdown became a household word and continues to be today as well.

The reason many veterinary team members offer for the practice is that pets seem calmer and easier to handle when separated from their owners. Others say this isn’t because their fear, anxiety, and stress (FAS) are reduced but because the pet is shutting down out of fear and/or in a state of learned helplessness. What exactly is the effect of separation from owners and transport to a different room during a veterinary visit on a pet’s FAS?

In a study published in the Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, researchers conducted a prospective non-blinded randomized two-period two-treatment crossover trial with 21 healthy adult cats. Each cat received an initial examination with their owner present to establish a baseline, and then they were divided into two groups. The cats were chosen from patients of a university veterinary teaching hospital’s wellness and dental care service and had previously been seen without any history of needing “undue restraint,” sedation, or anxiolytics to be examined.

The first group of cats received an examination in a treatment area without their owner, and the second received an examination in an exam room with their owner present. The actual order of the exam itself was randomized, and handling techniques described as “low-stress” were utilized. All veterinary team members had completed Fear Free certification to standardize handling and assessment.

The examining veterinarians recorded heart rate (HR) as measured by auscultation and also established a FAS score for each cat. The baseline HR for cats in the study averaged 176 beats per minute (BPM). For cats examined in the treatment area without their owners, mean HR was 226 bpm and 195 when measured in the exam room with owners present.

The most frequent values when measuring FAS scores were 3 at baseline (moderate stress), 4 in the exam room with owner present, and 5 in the treatment area without owner.

The authors wrote, “Results from this study indicate that minimizing transfer between examination areas and including the owner during wellness examinations can reduce some of the more overt signs of stress in cats during clinic visits. The data also suggest more proactive owner education measures may be of benefit, such as methods of owner habituation of their pet for transport and handling ahead of scheduled clinic visits.”

Note: This study was partially funded by Fear Free, which had no role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

This article was reviewed/edited by board-certified veterinary behaviorist Dr. Kenneth Martin and/or veterinary technician specialist in behavior Debbie Martin, LVT.

Christie Keith is a journalist, editor, and communications consultant with an exclusive
focus on animal welfare and veterinary medicine. She is a Fear Free Shelters graduate
and Elite Fear Free Certified professional.

Want to learn more about Fear Free? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop on upcoming events, specials, courses, and more by clicking here. 

Barbara Heidenreich

Before you can care for avian patients, clients must first get them to your clinic. Often, that’s easier said than done. Most companion birds are not used to leaving their home or riding in cars, and it can be frightening for them.

Reducing or eliminating distress for the avian companion starts before the patient arrives at the veterinary clinic. This is because transportation to the clinic can be a critical part of the process. Most avian companions rarely travel outside of the home. This means travel may have the potential to be challenging. Training birds for transportation in advance can give clients peace of mind and make it more likely that avian patients will receive regular annual examinations and necessary medical attention in a timely manner.

Transport Container Selection

Training for transport first requires finding an appropriate container. Some manufacturers have designed small travel cages, crates, and backpacks specifically for companion birds. However, other products such as plastic kennels or wire crates designed for dogs and cats can be adapted to work well for birds. Buyers should examine these products closely to ensure that the materials are safe and suitably indestructible, depending on the species identified for training.

An ideal container is comfortable, inviting, and easy to train the bird to use. This may require that the client add and position perching of the appropriate size for the species in training. Birds with long tails, like macaws, may require perching to be placed closer to one end to allow them to sit comfortably in the crate or cage. The container should have enough space for the bird to easily turn around.

Some containers provide more than one door, large doors, or unobstructed openings that make it easier for birds to enter voluntarily. This can facilitate training the bird to willingly enter a container for transport.

While it is tempting to put many toys inside a travel container, be careful to avoid hanging toys that can swing into the bird during car movement. This can create an unpleasant experience. Alternative options to consider include small foot toys that can be placed on the bottom of the crate or items that can be secured to the sides that won’t move.

Training to Enter the Transport Container

Training the bird to enter the travel container involves a series of steps. The first step is to give the bird time to habituate to the new crate or portable cage. This involves giving the bird time to see the travel container without any requirement to engage with it. This can be done by placing the crate or cage within viewing distance, while making sure the bird is calm and relaxed in its presence.

The next steps are to encourage interaction with the travel container. The initial interaction can be started by luring. Luring involves placing preferred items in a trail from outside that leads to inside the travel container. This can include food items and toys. For some birds, providing attention can also work.

If the bird knows how to orient their beak toward an object, like a ball on a stick or the tip of a chopstick to earn desired outcomes (also known as targeting), this behavior can also be used to guide the bird into the crate.

Subsequent steps include reinforcing for allowing the door to be closed for short increments of time. This is followed by reinforcing for allowing the container to be picked up with the bird in it. Over time, the container, with the bird inside, is moved for short distances.

Another important step in the shaping plan is to practice driving the bird in the container in the car. It is recommended to start with short trips around the block. Placement of the container may be important to prevent motion sickness for some individuals. Being able to see where they are going can help. If possible, advise clients to place the carrier in the front seat, raised so that the bird can see out the window. They shouldn’t cover the carrier or place it on the floor or in the back of the vehicle.

If clients report regurgitation, advise them on options to prevent motion sickness. Additionally, driving prior to feeding a meal can help reduce nausea.

Addressing Fear Responses

If the avian companion shows a fear response to transport containers due to prior experiences, another strategy is to use distance as a reinforcer for calm behavior in the presence of the travel container. This is done by starting far enough away from the container that the bird’s behavior is relaxed and calm.

Rather than getting closer and closer to the container, the client should approach the container only to a point at which the bird remains relaxed and comfortable, and then retreat from the container. This teaches the bird that calm body language at that distance results in moving away from the container. This is repeated and the distance between the bird and the container is decreased with each approximation.

Eventually the bird is very close to the container, showing relaxed behavior, and the procedure is switched to the steps utilizing the approach previously described. Learn more about how to use distance as a reinforcer in the Fear Free course Addressing Fear & Aggression in Avian Patients: A Constructional Approach.

Training for transportation is a behavior that can be taught even if a bird doesn’t know how to step up on hands or is not entirely comfortable with people. It is an important first step toward making an avian veterinary visit Fear Free. More details about training for transportation and how to train other behaviors to facilitate caring for avian patients are available in the Fear Free Veterinary Certification Program – Avian.

This article was reviewed/edited by board-certified veterinary behaviorist Dr. Kenneth Martin and/or veterinary technician specialist in behavior Debbie Martin, LVT.

Barbara Heidenreich is an animal training consultant specializing in exotic animals. She consults worldwide working with zoos, universities, veterinary professionals, and conservation projects. She has worked onsite with over 80 facilities in 27 countries. She is an adjunct instructor at Texas A & M University. She has authored two books and contributed to four veterinary textbooks. She is a coauthor of two Fear Free® Avian Certification Courses. Much of her work focuses on training exotic species to cooperate in medical care. Barbara is an advisor for the Animal Training Working Group and the Parrot Taxon Advisory Group for the European Association of Zoos and Aquariums. She has provided her expertise to conservation projects The Kakapo Recovery Program and The Borneo Orangutan Survival Foundation. Her goal is to leave behind a legacy of kindness to animals by sharing her expertise.

Want to learn more about Fear Free? Sign up for our newsletter to stay in the loop on upcoming events, specials, courses, and more by clicking here.